Why Eli Manning shouldn’t play again for the Giants this season

Why Eli Manning shouldn't play again for the Giants this season

The Giants have not done much right since Super Bowl XLVI.

And the missteps over the last decade have been well-documented.

One of best moments they’ve had was what transpired in Sunday’s 36-20 victory over the Dolphins, somewhat organically, in what turned out to be a pseudo-farewell at MetLife Stadium to Eli Manning.

If Daniel Jones can’t play against the Redskins this Sunday, play Alex Tanney at quarterback.Yes, it is understandable that such a decision would conflict with what Manning has proposed as a competitor during his decorated 16 years as quarterback of the Giants.

There are two ways to look at the events that took place Sunday.

Was this just a special moment for Manning, or was this a deserved farewell for Manning, a player adored by a fan base that has endured plenty of gut punches since their team last held the Vince Lombardi Trophy eight years ago?

Are they one in the same? Do they have to be?

Related image

Any debate about preserving the moment for Manning and the fans is moot if Jones is healthy and returns as anticipated at Washington.We’ll find out more on Wednesday when the Giants hit the practice field and prepare for the last two games of what is still a lost season, two games that may indicate a shift for the organization with the future of coach Pat Shurmur and general manager Dave Gettleman still uncertain.

Maybe Shurmur is right when he said Monday that we’re overthinking it when it comes to Manning and who plays.

Remember this: the Yankees orchestrated Mariano Rivera’s exit much in the same way the Giants did for Manning, and Rivera didn’t pitch again. That was his choice. It’s hard to argue against giving Manning when the circumstance arises, but Sunday was the end that he deserves.

I was surprised they set up the curtain call for Manning by bringing Tanney in with 1:50 remaining. It’s so anti-Eli. Was Rivera looking for a participation trophy when he decided he wouldn’t throw that weekend after his farewell in the Bronx?

The only difference here – and granted, it’s potentially a big one — is that Manning has not announced his retirement.

Considering the emotions Sunday, It’s hard to imagine a better scenario to complete the Manning era. We can try to write a script for the next two games by saying: what if Manning beats the Redskins, what if he plays well against the Eagles, but all that is part of the unpredictable mystery of the game day.

The Giants and Manning have their end in the current composition. No reason to keep looking for a better one that might not come.

Written by Emma Fisher

TV Writer.
Former Senior Editor of

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Bold and Beautiful Spoilers: Hope Logan Reports to Brooke Logan About Zoe’s Return

Angelina Pivarnick and ‘90 Day Fiancé’ star Ashley Martson get into fight after charity event