Stagecoach 2024 just turned into Bachelor Nation’s unofficial rodeo, and the buzz is real. The desert became a wild reunion spot filled with reality stars, influencer fashion, and relationship rumors. At the center of it all? Jason Tartick and Kelley Flanagan. Yes — again.
Photos and videos from the weekend showed the former flames spending time together, leading fans to scream reunion rumors. “Everywhere I look, Jason and Kelley!” wrote one user. Another added, “I ship Jason and Kelley. I actually think they would make a great couple.”
Even more telling? Kelley reportedly said she and Jason talk weekly and might be spending the summer together in the Hamptons. “Jason is definitely interested,” one fan claimed, citing recent interviews where Jason gushed about Kelley, calling her “kind, funny, smart, and beautiful.”
But Kelley’s camp insists it’s just friendship — for now. Following her father’s passing and a recent breakup, insiders say she’s “not ready to date.” But in Bachelor Nation, intentions change faster than a Stagecoach outfit.
Bachelor Nation: Jenn WHO? Fans Call Out Her Erasure As Sparks Fly Elsewhere
While Jason and Kelley soaked up the spotlight, fans were quick to point out someone was missing: Jenn. The same Jenn who had a romantic connection with Jason not that long ago. “The Jenn erasure is heinous,” one Redditor slammed.
The timeline gets even messier considering Jason and Kelley were both once involved with Pilot Pete. As one fan joked, “Jason clearly has a type.” Another said, “Peter recently told Kelley they have a brother-sister dynamic… sounds like he gave his blessing.”
Still, not everyone’s on board. “Jason is disgustingly hot here,” one fan gushed, while another fired back: “Nah, I’ve never found Jason attractive at all.”
@kelleyflanagan 36 hour trip from LA to NYC for the #usweekly #maidenform ♬ original sound – kelleyflanagan
From BIP Hints to Cowboy Cosplay: Bachelor Nation’s Wild Desert Takeover
Beyond the love tension, Bachelor stars brought maximum drama and minimal fabric. Charity stunned in every shot — “She looks like a Barbie, it’s insane,” a viewer raved — while others questioned the vibe entirely. “This festival is deeply insufferable and fake country as hell,” another wrote.
The fashion choices? Unhinged. Fans called it “cowboy cosplay” with one summing it up perfectly: “The men go full cowboy. The women wear normal outfits but slap on a hat and boots.”
Stagecoach has unofficially become Bachelor in Paradise: Pre-Game, with one user joking, “They’re going directly from Stagecoach to the beach.” Hannah Brown reportedly confirmed this, telling fans she was squeezing in time with her fiancé before filming BIP.
Bachelor Nation: Micah, Lace, and Milk Dancing—The Rest of the Stagecoach Madness
It wasn’t just Jason and Kelley stirring the pot. Fans were shocked to spot Micah from Love Is Blind mingling with Zach’s Bachelor girls. “It’s giving influencer summer camp,” one said. Another added, “Why are they so buddy-buddy with Micah? That’s a red flag.”
And let’s talk fashion. One commenter called it a “moment in fashion history everyone’s going to cringe at later.” Natalie looked unrecognizable in a group shot, which caused a buzz. People also whispered about Nick Viall’s hand on her waist. This moment sparked even more confusion.
Then came the viral milk-dancing video from Tyler Cameron’s girlfriend. Fans dragged the clip: “Watch at your own risk,” one warned. Another summed it up with a hard pass: “This festival would be my personal hell.”
Share your thoughts in the comments!
