Things got weird-fast-at the end of the Sister Wives: One-on-One Part 2 special on June 1.
In what’s now being dubbed the most awkward moment of the season, Kody Brown’s entire face went blank when host Sukanya Krishnan revealed that Christine and her new husband David Woolley were actually open to a future relationship with Kody and Robyn.
Yes, they said yes to the guys trip and even a possible double date.
That’s when Kody-who just minutes before claimed that “they’d never come to a place of understanding”-suddenly fell silent. For nearly a full minute, the usually volatile father of 18 just stared. No words. No rant. No comeback. Nothing.
Viewers were stunned.
“I think he malfunctioned and crashed out and needed a reboot,” one viewer wrote.
“That was the most telling moment of the entire special,” another said.
“He only felt safe pretending he’d want to, because he never thought they’d agree to it,” another fan added.
“That moment showed how scary and dangerous he can be,” someone warned.
Who said anything about a double date? Oh, right — Kody did. 😬 Don’t miss part two of the #SisterWives Tell All tonight at 10/9c. pic.twitter.com/6c5gxWHKwY
— TLC Network (@TLC) June 1, 2025
Sister Wives: Fans Compare Kody to Manson, Call Behavior “Creepy” and “Psycho”
The reaction online was intense. And savage.
Multiple viewers said the moment gave them serious serial killer vibes. Others didn’t hold back with comparisons:
“Charles Manson!!!”
“Creepy psycho!”
“I got major scary vibes… then he’d just flip back to laughing.”
“He looked like a malfunctioning robot trying to calculate how to save face.”
Theories poured in about why Kody froze. Some believed it was because Robyn wasn’t there to tell him what to say. Others felt the moment proved that Kody only ever pretends to want peace—as long as it’s on his terms.
“He realized agreeing would make Christine look good and ruin his ‘victim’ story,” one fan explained.
“His entire strategy depends on being rejected,” another pointed out.
“Robyn probably told him not to go. He panicked.”
And yes-many noticed that Kody’s classic angry stare likely wasn’t new to Christine, Meri, or Janelle.
“That stare-down was familiar to all the ex-wives. Guaranteed.”
Sister Wives: Christine and David Flip the Script: “We’d Do It”
The real twist came when Christine and David completely flipped the script-and fans loved every second.
When Sukanya shared Kody’s idea about a guys trip, Christine said, “You’d have a good time!” while David added, “We could do that.”
Christine even said a double date might be possible someday, admitting she’d be nervous but open. “I’d be a mess, but David would have me,” she said.
Kody didn’t expect this. He’d just told the audience that reconciliation was hopeless. But when faced with actual kindness and maturity from his ex and her new man, all he could do was glare. Then, a few seconds later, he muttered, “There are no more words to be said.”
Viewers weren’t buying it.
“He was caught off guard because the answer didn’t fit his victim narrative,” one fan commented.
“He talks big but never wants real resolution,” another noted.
Share your thoughts in the comments!
