Whitney Thore turned 41 and celebrated in style. She didn’t just have cake; her big weight loss reveal stunned the internet. The star of My Big Fat Fabulous Life shared sleek Instagram photos. They show her slimmer figure, glowing skin, and defined facial features.
“41 🎂✨,” she wrote in the caption, keeping it short and sweet. But the images said plenty – one showed Whitney gazing out at a scenic landscape in a flowing white dress that cinched at her now-smaller waist. Another showcased her cuddled up with her loyal pup, flaunting a visibly leaner face and sharper jawline.
Fans immediately flooded the comments with praise. “You look stunning!” one wrote. Another added, “So proud of the hard work you’ve been putting in!”
But behind the Instagram applause was a growing wave of skepticism – and it’s only getting louder.
My Big Fat Fabulous Life: “Who Does She Think She’s Fooling?”
While Instagram fans were mostly supportive, Reddit told a very different story. A now-viral thread titled “Who does she think she’s fooling?” had users pointing out what they believe are major inconsistencies in Whitney’s appearance and narrative.
“The editing is diabolical,” one user claimed. “The hair alone…” Others called her out for allegedly wearing a wig and using extreme photo filters. “That is a WIG!” another commenter insisted, with many agreeing she’s no longer addressing the hair loss caused by her PCOS — something she previously opened up about.
One Redditor wrote, “Let your viewers in on what was successful for her hair regrowth instead of gatekeeping… this one is obviously a wig, but you can tell by the other pics she posts that she’s had some hair regrowth.”
My Big Fat Fabulous Life: Ozempic Accusations Explode: “Just Be Honest About It”
Whitney has claimed she lost 100 pounds naturally, especially during her mother’s illness and passing. However, many fans aren’t convinced.
“Like she’s on Ozempic or something,” one Reddit user speculated. Another added, “Oh oh oh Ozempic, of course she’s on it.” While there’s no confirmation that Whitney is using any GLP-1 medications, that hasn’t stopped the speculation — or frustration.
One particularly fired-up comment read, “She built her career on embracing fatness. Of course, she doesn’t want to credit a drug for her weight loss.”
Another user urged honesty: “She might have tipped into actual diabetes and doesn’t have a choice but to use the meds. And that’s fine! Just say so.”
Some fans believe she’s doing a disservice to others who struggle with PCOS and obesity by not being transparent. “She could really elevate herself by lifting others up,” one Redditor wrote. “She’s missing out on a real opportunity to help people like her.”
My Big Fat Fabulous Life: Is Whitney Thore Lying About Her Weight Loss? Fans Say “Yes”
Even longtime followers are growing weary of the conflicting messages. Whitney shares photos that look slimmer, but she denies losing much weight.
“She gets downright hostile when someone congratulates her on the weight loss,” one fan wrote. “Then straight up lies and says she’s only lost 5 pounds. Like, girl… we saw how big you were. Just let us know how you did it.”
Others compared her to Lizzo, suggesting that both built empires on body positivity but have backtracked. “She’s kind of like Lizzo who made a whole business off of fat bitches and then claimed she loved being fat and now look,” someone said.
The sentiment? You don’t have to stay the same — just don’t pretend you are.
Share your thoughts in the comments!
