Jasmine Pineda might have hoped her baby news would bring joy. Instead, it’s brought major skepticism. On April 9, 2025, the 90 Day Fiancé star revealed she had welcomed her daughter, Matilda, with boyfriend Matt Branistareanu.
The couple posed with their bundle of joy in a sweet photo shoot, with Jasmine cradling the baby proudly. But almost immediately, fans took to social media to call out one glaring issue: the baby doesn’t look newborn.
“That baby is already 3–4 months old 🤣,” one viewer commented. Another added, “That baby already got a W-2 and ready to pay bills!” The baby’s eyebrows and alertness have raised eyebrows of their own.
The big question? When was baby Matilda actually born?
90 Day Fiancé: Fans Dissect the Timeline – And Something Doesn’t Add Up
The skepticism isn’t just about how the baby looks — it’s about the timeline. Jasmine previously appeared pregnant during The Last Resort, which filmed in early 2024. Fans have been analyzing photos from the resort, the tell-all, and her social media for months.
In February 2024, Jasmine posted a pic with the caption “baby food” — and what looked like a bump. Even earlier, she reportedly had a baby registry full of pink items. At the January 2025 tell-all taping, Jasmine looked well into her third trimester. Yet she claims she just gave birth in April?
Some think Jasmine was pregnant before her estranged husband, Gino Palazzolo, accepted an open marriage. Was the “babymoon” with Matt just a cover story?
90 Day Fiancé: Jasmine Hints Baby Was Born Weeks Ago – Fans Say It Was Months
Jasmine stirred things up by sharing an edited post from a birth photographer. It revealed that baby Matilda was born three weeks ago, not on April 9 as previously stated.
Sara Hunter, the photographer, wrote:
“Three weeks earlier, Ms. Lucie, the midwife called me at 4 a.m. and said, ‘I need you here, NOW!!!’”
This small detail set fans off again. If Jasmine’s own circle is saying “three weeks earlier,” could the real birthdate be even further back?
Many now speculate that baby Matilda may have arrived in late 2024.
90 Day Fiancé: Gino Drama Reignites: Did Jasmine Conceal Pregnancy from Her Husband?
The timing has even darker implications. Jasmine debuted on TLC with Gino Palazzolo in Before the 90 Days, and their chaotic love story continued through The Last Resort.
Fans recall Jasmine sharing her pregnancy news after Gino agreed to an open marriage. This was a desperate move to save their relationship.
“As terrible as an open marriage sounds, this might be the only way to keep Jasmine in my life,” Gino admitted on-air. Yet it now seems possible Jasmine was already expecting Matt’s child at the time.
In the Last Resort season 2 tell-all, Gino confirmed:
“Normally I come in here and I have good news for you, but today I don’t. Because Jasmine and I, we separated.”
If Jasmine hid her pregnancy timeline from Gino, it could completely change how fans view the already messy love triangle.
Share your thoughts in the comments!
