Leah, the daughter of Amber Portwood and Gary Shirley, is finally speaking her truth. In a shocking scene, the teen talked about her tough relationship with her birth mother.
Fans applauded Leah’s composure and maturity during the conversation. “She’s so level headed and understanding, especially at her age,” one Reddit user posted. Another added, “Leah is my favorite Teen Mom kid. She knows where her limits are and knows how to protect herself.” Many were impressed that Leah, just 15, could express clearly that her emotional boundaries are more important than family appearances.
But what was meant to be a heartfelt exchange has instead ignited outrage. Viewers are now calling out the show for dragging minors into adult drama. “These kids should be out with their friends, not filming for their parents’ stupid TV show,” one furious fan wrote. Another added, “It’s gross to exploit a child’s trauma for TV.”
Teen Mom: Cate and Maci Face Hypocrisy Claims After Leah Conversation
The segment featured Catelynn Lowell and Maci Bookout engaging in what appeared to be a supportive talk with Leah. But viewers weren’t buying it. “Cate talking to Leah about setting boundaries while ignoring Brandon and Teresa’s boundaries is rich,” one post read. Another went further, calling it “a puddle letting a river know how to flow better.”
Fans quickly pointed out that both Cate and Maci have long defended Amber’s behavior over the years. Now, their sudden pivot to concern for Leah is being called “performative” and “scripted.” One comment summed it up: “Cate using Leah to protect her reputation… low.”
The chat got really hypocritical when Cate complimented Leah for avoiding a toxic parent. Viewers say this goes against how she treats her own mom. “She leaves her kids alone with April but wants to preach boundaries? Please,” one fan snapped.
Teen Mom: Viewers Demand MTV Stop Exploiting the Kids
One of the biggest takeaways from the viral backlash is clear: fans are over seeing the next generation of Teen Mom kids being pulled into the chaos. “It’s disgusting how they throw these kids into adult conversations,” someone commented. Another noted, “At what point do the kids start getting paychecks for being exploited on camera?”
Critics also pointed out the irony of adults — especially those with their own ongoing issues — putting Leah on the spot about her mom. “Imagine letting your kid talk to this psycho,” one person wrote, referring to Cate. Another added, “Cate and Maci acting like a voice of reason for Leah is comical.”
Leah’s choice to go no contact with Amber was praised across the board. “She deserves peace and consistency,” one Redditor said. “Amber will forever blame everyone but herself. Leah’s protecting herself, and that’s what matters.”
Fans were particularly appalled by how the show seems to be focusing more and more on the kids’ emotional baggage. “This is why Chelsea Houska got out. To protect Aubree,” one fan declared. “MTV is testing the waters for a Teen Grandma spinoff and it’s icky.”
Leah Wins Viewer Respect — Amber’s Supporters Called Out
Amid all the drama, one thing is clear: viewers are standing with Leah. “She’s so strong,” one person wrote. “I hope she never doubts herself for setting those boundaries.” Another agreed, “Even adults can’t communicate like that — Leah is lightyears ahead emotionally.”
Meanwhile, Amber’s past behavior continues to haunt her public image. Viewers recalled past moments clearly. They remembered threatening Andrew with a machete while holding their baby. They also recalled letting a stranger change Leah’s diaper as an infant. “Amber didn’t earn the title of mom,” one fan concluded. “She’s an egg donor.”
Kristina and Gary, however, are being praised. “Leah decided to call Kristina mom all on her own,” one fan pointed out. “Gary tried for years to give Amber a chance. But he finally started listening to Leah. That’s what a good parent does.”
Share your thoughts in the comments!
