You’ve heard Robyn Brown talk about her faith’s unique rules on Sister Wives before, but fans aren’t buying it this time. Robyn once claimed, “In our church, you’re not really divorced until you’ve been with another man.” And now, many believe she used Kody Brown to officially end things with her ex-husband—long before they were ever married.
Kody and Robyn have always insisted they followed the “law of chastity” before tying the knot. But with Christine Brown now saying she doesn’t believe it, fans are re-examining old clips and timelines. Christine openly questioned, “They just seemed too comfortable, too early on. It didn’t feel like courting.”
It gets worse. Robyn once explained that her first marriage was supposed to be polygamous, but it never happened. Still, she had three children in that relationship. Her claim that it wasn’t “truly plural” left viewers confused and suspicious. Especially since she later turned herself into the unofficial spokesperson for polygamy. One fan put it bluntly: “Her stories just don’t add up anymore.”
New revelations and new beginnings. #SisterWives returns Sunday, April 20 at 10/9c on TLC. pic.twitter.com/yjgmIppXLH
— TLC Network (@TLC) March 20, 2025
Sister Wives: Christine Drops a Bombshell: “They Were Kissing Before the Wedding!”
Christine Brown Woolley isn’t holding back anymore. In a jaw-dropping sneak peek for the Sister Wives Season 19 Tell-All, she accuses Robyn and Kody of crossing lines way before the wedding bells rang. “He didn’t kiss me until we were married. Same with Janelle,” she says. “But with Robyn? That kiss happened way too early.”
You might remember the infamous kiss that caused a storm back in Season 1. Robyn and Kody shared a romantic moment that should’ve only come after marriage—according to their religious values. Yet, they brushed it off as a minor slip. But Christine’s version of events suggests a lot more went on behind closed doors.
Fans have long believed Robyn was treated differently. Kody traveled five hours just to visit her during their courtship. Allegedly, he’d bring his older kids along so it wouldn’t seem suspicious. But more often than not, they were just there to babysit Robyn’s children while Kody took her out solo. Convenient, right?
Sister Wives: The Last Marriage Standing-But At What Cost?
Now that Meri, Janelle, and Christine are gone, Robyn is the only one left. But fans are starting to think she may have planned it that way all along. As one viewer put it, “She played the long game. And Kody was her ticket out.”
With Christine now remarried and Janelle living her best single life, Robyn and Kody’s dynamic is under more scrutiny than ever. And as Season 19 continues, more cracks are showing in the fairytale they’ve tried so hard to sell. The engagement photo Robyn proudly displays in her home has also raised eyebrows. Fans say it “doesn’t match the timeline” of their supposed courtship rules.
What’s most telling is how often Robyn’s story has changed over the years. She went from a quiet newcomer to the voice of authority on all things polygamy—while living a life that looks pretty monogamous today. Kody even admitted that he’s now “basically a one-woman man.”
So the real question remains: Did Robyn rewrite the rules to get what she wanted? And did Kody help her do it?
Sister Wives: Fans Brace for the Most Explosive Tell-All Yet
With the Sister Wives Tell-All right around the corner, all eyes are on what Kody and Robyn will say when confronted. Will they deny Christine’s claims? Or will another bombshell come to light?
You’ve watched the drama unfold for nearly 15 years. But this next chapter could be the most jaw-dropping yet. One fan summed it up perfectly: “This isn’t the family we met in Season 1. It’s Robyn’s world now—and Kody’s just living in it.”
Share your thoughts in the comments!
