The most emotionally raw episode of Sister Wives to date aired last night—and viewers were not ready. The tribute to Garrison Brown, following his tragic death, shattered the usual reality TV mold. There were no gimmicks. No forced drama. Just real pain.
“It was the most real episode we’ve ever seen,” one viewer commented. “No scripted drama, just real people living through real grief.” Kody Brown, often criticized for his detachment, showed visible regret and sorrow. “I really hope that they find a little bit of peace,” another fan wrote.
Janelle Brown, Garrison’s mother, reminded many why she has remained a viewer favorite. Her loyalty to her children and her calm strength during heartbreak inspired many. Meri’s emotional scene was particularly wrenching. One social media admitted, “As soon as they jumped to that scene with Meri, I was done for.”
On the next Sister Wives, Janelle, Kody, and the Browns begin to process an unimaginable loss.
— TLC Network (@TLC) May 5, 2025
If you or someone you know is struggling or in crisis, help is available. Call or text 988 to reach the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline or chat at https://t.co/aXTqjIURZQ pic.twitter.com/ugqfnreDoA
Sister Wives: Kody Brown’s Regret and Robyn’s Cold Comfort
Kody Brown’s breakdown caught many by surprise. For the first time in seasons, viewers saw what looked like genuine remorse. “Good for Kody for having a sliver of self-reflection,” one user wrote. “He regrets making Covid a big deal and how he doesn’t get the chance to fix it now.”
However, the episode’s most divisive element came in the form of Robyn Brown. Her discomfort during Kody’s vulnerable moments was obvious. “She looked so uncomfortable,” one commenter said. “She is uncomfortable because she knows the role she played in denying those kids any family time with their dad.”
Despite some defending Robyn for remaining quiet, many viewers weren’t convinced. Her reaction was labeled by some as “performed” and “insincere.” One viewer wrote, “Even Caleb and Tony were choked up. Not Robyn. She just did the same look-up, fake cry face.”
Sister Wives: Grief, Isolation, and Missed Opportunities
As the episode unfolded, deeper emotional wounds came to light. Fans noted that Kody’s strict COVID rules, backed by Robyn, hurt his bonds with his older kids. “Kody got mad with Janelle because she was allowing [the boys] to still live at home,” a user remembered. “But Garrison was struggling at that time. The last thing to do is push him away.”
Viewers connected the dots between those tense pandemic days and the lasting emotional damage. “Garrison started drinking during COVID,” another fan pointed out. “Did Kody even know any of his struggles?”
Even Robyn’s emotional detachment couldn’t distract from the overwhelming praise for Janelle and Meri. “Meri reacted more as a mother would, saying something about one of ‘our kids’,” one commenter noted. Fans praised her for maintaining boundaries, yet immediately taking the emergency call from Kody.
Sister Wives: A Devastating but Necessary Tribute
Though emotionally grueling, many fans agreed that the episode was essential. “It was a beautiful tribute to both Garrison and the complexities of grief,” one viewer reflected. Even those critical of TLC applauded the network’s restraint. “TLC did an excellent job,” a fan wrote. “But the jump cuts to dating show previews after were jarring.”
The episode touched everyone. It resonated with viewers who’ve experienced personal loss and those grieving with the Browns. This brought up shared pain and hard truths. “Suicide adds a whole different level of grief,” one Redditor shared. “Changed everything forever.”
The audience might never see this family the same way again. “It should have been a uniting situation,” one commenter concluded, “and all it’s done is push them farther from him.”
Share your thoughts in the comments!
